Donald Trump victory threatens to throw G20 initiatives into disarray
Argentina veto warning sparks fears conservatives will be emboldened to ditch global deals on climate and tax
Donald Trump’s election as US president is already threatening international initiatives on climate change and taxation, as diplomats from the world’s richest nations struggle to maintain a shaky consensus on the eve of a G20 summit in Brazil.
Argentina and its President Javier Milei, a close ally of Trump, threatened to block a joint communiqué set to be endorsed by G20 leaders at the Rio de Janeiro meeting that begins on Monday, because of objections related to taxation of the super-rich and gender equality, people briefed on the negotiations told the Financial Times.
Diplomats were racing to reach a final consensus on statements related to climate finance and geopolitical issues such as Russia’s war against Ukraine, the people said, as leaders began arriving in the Brazilian city.
Negotiators for the 20 participant nations, plus the EU and African Union, said a compromise text had been circulated for preliminary approval on Sunday evening, but it was unclear whether all countries would ultimately agree to it.
Brazilian officials were expecting bilateral negotiations with the Argentine delegation, said a person briefed on the talks.
The struggle to agree on how much developing nations should contribute to financial efforts to combat global warming mirrored negotiations at the UN COP29 climate summit taking place simultaneously in Baku.
Milei’s stance has heightened the concerns of many western diplomats who fear Trump’s election will embolden his conservative allies and spark an exodus of countries from ambitious agreements on issues such as global warming. Trump has vowed to pull the US out of the Paris climate accords.
“[The Argentine government] wants to make the G20 in Brazil a test between old and new forces,” said one Brazilian official. “After a year of negotiations on taxation and consensus they are creating problems on things they accepted before, word by word.”
Buenos Aires’ opposition to the initial draft communiqué prepared by the leaders’ representatives in the Brazilian city followed Milei’s talks with Trump in Florida on Thursday, in the US president-elect’s first meeting with a foreign leader since his poll victory.
Argentina was the only country to vote against a UN resolution last week denouncing online violence against women and girls.
Sir Keir Starmer, UK prime minister, denied that Milei’s scepticism on climate change and the imminent arrival of Trump in the White House was a death knell for global co-operation on the issue. “No I don’t think so,” he said.
Starmer, recently returned from the UN climate talks in Baku, told reporters on his way to Rio: “Amongst the reasons I went to COP last week was because I think it’s important for the UK to show leadership on an important issue.”
When asked about Argentina’s stance, António Guterres, UN secretary-general, told reporters in Rio: “We are seeing some negotiations in the G20, and I am asking all the countries to have a spirit of consensus . . . to transform this meeting to one of success. If G20 will be split, it will lose its global leverage and influence.”
The Rio summit, where Brazilian president Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva will convene discussions focused on combating poverty, governance reform in international institutions and climate, is the first gathering of leaders from the world’s most powerful countries since the US election, after many skipped the COP29 summit.
Many officials present at the event — where Lula is to launch a global alliance against hunger — fear it will be overshadowed by the knowledge that Trump is opposed to many of its planned conclusions.
“We’re all supposed to sit there and talk about the future of global co-operation and pretend that there’s not this guy on his way [to the White House] who couldn’t care less,” said a European official involved in the communiqué negotiations. “It’s hard to see how anything decided [here] has much of a future.”
Argentina objected to the inclusion of language around taxation that Milei’s government agreed to last month at a meeting of G20 finance ministers and central bank governors, according to people briefed on the talks.
The October declaration pledged to “work together towards a fairer, more inclusive, stable and efficient international tax system fit for the 21st century, restating our commitment to tax transparency and fostering global dialogue on effective taxation, including of ultra-high-net-worth individuals”.
Milei was also opposed to a reference to the Paris agreement and a commitment to “stay united in the pursuit of the accord’s goals”, officials said. Another point of Argentine resistance was reference to the US’s 2030 agenda on sustainable development.
Milei pulled his team of negotiators from the COP29 summit this week, as negotiators in Baku grapple with trying to make progress on a deal to raise more global funds for climate finance.
The struggle to agree the G20 communiqué added to existing tensions within the group over Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and the war in the Middle East.
Russian President Vladimir Putin will not attend the Rio summit, but his Chinese counterpart Xi Jinping is expected to continue Beijing’s position of blocking western efforts to condemn Moscow for the war against its neighbour.
It will also be the final summit for US President Joe Biden, whose administration sought to leverage multilateral organisations such as Nato, the G7 and G20 to find responses to issues such as the Ukraine war.
“So, all this work that we have done with the US [under Biden] — what do we do with it now?” said a senior European diplomat. “We have lost the initiative.”
